Finding Grace in the Heart of Pedagogy

A Note from Matt: Last week I wrote about how it seems that everyone I talk to is experiencing this global crisis in dramatically different ways. This has been especially true for my students, who’ve reported wildly different reactions, ranging from feeling stressed at the lack of school to being relieved to not have school’s stresses, exhausted to well-rested, angry to indifferent, and desperate for instruction to not wanting any school work at all. This wide variety of experiences has made planning lessons particularly tricky, as I know that my students are in very different places, and many of them are in very different place than me. Because of the range of experiences for both students and teachers, I have been regularly turning to amazing teachers I know across the country to ask what they are doing, and many of their answers have been instrumental in helping me to create a class that better supports my students and keeps learning moving forward as much as possible.

So this week, I plan to share what some of those teachers who have helped me to shape my thinking are doing, in the hope that hearing about other classrooms will help you too. Today, the first in this mini-series is from Andy Schoenborn, former Michigan Council of Teachers of English president, a leader of the Chippewa River Writing Project, co-author with Troy Hicks of the wonderful upcoming book Creating Confident Writers, and one of the best teachers I know, talking about the essential role that grace plays in teaching during a pandemic. I hope you enjoy!

Finding Grace in the Heart of Pedagogy

by Andy Schoenborn

March 13th, 2020 was the last time I saw my students face-to-face. We gathered our books, pens, papers and docked our Chromebooks in the charging station. We cleaned out our lockers and classrooms. We joked a bit about the COVID-19 “apocalypse” and I said, “See you in three weeks!” On a whim, before I left, I looked at my classroom library and tucked Mary Oliver’s Devotions, Ross Gay’s Catalog of Unabashed Gratitude, and John Warner’s The Writer’s Practice under my arm, turned off the lights, and closed my classroom door.

I didn’t say goodbye. I didn’t think I had to say goodbye.

As of April 13th, 2020 – a full month removed – I missed my students and longed to reconnect with them through beautiful words. Words we lift with our voices and words that are drawn to the page when we write. 

And, though I wasn’t officially required to begin learning with students, the desire was strong. So, I created a Google Classroom and Remind accounts and invited students to join me in forty-five minutes virtual classes using Zoom. Virtual classes were optional and nothing would be graded or be counted for credit or no credit either. The intent was learning for the sake of learning. It was a good place to be.

With a new distance learning situation and all the stresses that come with it, I kept the heart of my pedagogy: learning opportunities that are personal, relevant, and authentic. In my view these are the big three lenses that encourage literacy and create confident writers. 

I proposed these ideas to my students and, in the awkwardness that is a Zoom classroom, they didn’t say much, but they did smile. The joy evident on their faces was enough to help me realize that thinking of students first, inviting literacy experiences they care about, and giving them a space to come together as writers was needed during our time apart. 

Recognizing the many creative ways educators have risen to the occasion, I chose to lean on NPR’s This I Believe, to encourage my seniors to think, write, and share about how COVID-19 has shaped their beliefs. Understanding the often therapeutic nature of writing poetry, I reached out to Dr. Sarah Donovan. Her #verselove prompts on have been a respite for thoughtful and authentic writing experiences. Additionally, my students and I have found Brett Vogelsinger’s Go Poems as creative, reflective, and authentic literacy outlets. 

For my juniors, The Quarantine Journal Project is sparking thinking, writing, and conversation that we share every other day. Staying true to our Michigan Merit Curriculum requirements we are exploring ethical dilemmas using the TED Talk playlist “New Tech, New Ethics” and collaboratively sharing what resonates, what worries, and what revolutionizes. Eventually we will explore our thinking around ethical dilemmas using John Warner’s ethical dilemma writing experience from his work The Writer’s Practice.

All of these experiences are delivered at a comfortable pace, without expectations of homework,  accessible on and offline (TED Talks have transcripts), and offered, most importantly, with grace in mind. It is true that only a small percentage of my students regularly join me in these virtual spaces – and that is okay. It is also true that I worry about inequity and have chosen these learning pathways with students in mind who are not able to join us online. 

As educators we find ourselves in the challenging space of wanting to give our students the best of ourselves and finding it a struggle at times. It is easy to be frustrated – I’ve been there too. I often compare what I am doing to reach my students with the brilliant ideas I see from educators on my social media feeds. Sometimes I am encouraged and sometimes I feel I am not enough. In the moments when I feel I am lacking, I dip into the grace I share with my students and give some to myself. It can be difficult, but a sip from the well of grace is refreshing and rejuvenating. Like water, grace (for ourselves and for our students), is what will help sustain us on our journey. 

In isolation, each of us has a desire for our voices to be seen and heard in ways that bring us together as a community. I am choosing to learn and grow together with my students, one day at a time, until we meet again in celebration and acknowledgement that we made it through a global crisis. One we will remember for a lifetime.

Andy Schoenborn is an award-winning author and high school English teacher in Michigan at Mt. Pleasant Public Schools. He focuses his work on progressive literacy methods including student-centered critical thinking, digital collaboration, and professional development. He is a co-facilitator of the monthly #TeachWrite Twitter chat, past-president of the Michigan Council of Teachers of English, and teacher consultant for the Chippewa River Writing Project. His first book, co-authored with Dr. Troy Hicks, Creating Confident Writers will be published June 2, 2020. Follow him on Twitter @aschoenborn.

Images below were taken by Julie Schoenborn and are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Permission for reuse, commercial or non-commercial, is granted.

If You Liked This…

Join my mailing list and I will send you a thoughtful post about finding balance and success as a writing teacher and a list of curated reading suggestions each week. Also, as a thank you for signing up, you will also receive a short ebook on how to cut feedback time without cutting feedback quality that is adapted from my newly released book Flash Feedback: Responding to Student Writing Better and Faster – Without Burning Out from Corwin Literacy.

One response to “Finding Grace in the Heart of Pedagogy”

  1. […] Note from Matt: This is the second in my mini-series about what various amazing writing teachers are doing across the country in their classes right […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: